AI elites might hoard intelligence like mercantilists hoarded gold
| Source: THE DECODER
Tags: Venkatesh Rao, Contraptions, cognitive mercantilism, open-weight models, AI labor economics
Engineer Venkatesh Rao argues that elites treat intelligence like mercantilists treated gold, as a scarce asset to control, and that cheap AI could instead raise demand for human thinking, so policy should focus on fair access rather than protecting legacy knowledge jobs.
Details
In an essay on his blog Contraptions, summarized by THE DECODER, engineer Venkatesh Rao compares today's fear of AI job losses to mercantilism, the doctrine that treated wealth such as land and gold as finite and ordinary people only as labor. Rao says many elites now treat intelligence the same way: a scarce, dangerous resource that experts should manage, keep expensive and withhold from rivals. In that frame, openly available models look like a threat, and some AI executives use safety fears for political influence. His counterexample is early capitalism, when people chose to work 300 days a year instead of 250 to buy goods like tea and sugar. AI could do something similar by making previously too-hard or too-costly projects feasible, so people think more, not less. Rao concludes that politics should prioritize fair access to AI, and that autonomous agents need guardrails but could also create new demand for intelligence by pursuing their own projects.